An
International Workshop
for the
Development of Research Strategies for the Sampling and Analysis
of Organic and Elemental Carbon Fractions in Atmospheric Aerosols
March
3-5, 2003
Durango, Colorado USA
(DOUBLE
TREE HOTEL)
Hosted by:
· Community Services, Fort Lewis College (host and coordination)
· Desert Research Institute (facilitator)
Made
possible with funding and support from:
· National Science Foundation
· EPA Office of Air Quality Planning & Standards
· EPA National Exposure Research Laboratory
· Environmental Protection Agency, Region 8
· National Park Service Intermountain Region
· Western Regional Air Partnership
Statement
of Problem—Elemental carbon, sometimes termed “black
carbon” or “soot,” is an important component
of suspended particles; however while methods that measure total
carbon usually provide equivalent values, those that measure the
EC portion of the total are widely variable. Since the EC is subtracted
from the total to obtain organic carbon, OC is equivalently different.
Periodic interlaboratory comparisons that have been conducted
reveal differences, but they do little to understand and resolve
the causes of discrepancies. A more fundamental approach is needed
to understand the reasons why these discrepancies exist and how
EC should be quantified for different purposes.
~
AGENDA ~
MONDAY MARCH 3, 2003
9
a.m. -
4 p.m.
|
—
Exclusively for lead presenters, facilitators, and scribes
to discuss topics, prepare for presentations, and begin outlining
and formatting workshop outcomes into a Research Strategy
— |
6:30
p.m. |
Registration
Begins |
7:00
p.m. |
Reception |
7:45
p.m. |
Welcome
by Dr. Stephen Roderick, Vice President of Academic
Affairs, Ft. Lewis College (Introduced by Tim
Richard) |
7:50
p.m. |
Workshop
Overview, background, context, purpose & process—
Dr. John Watson, DRI |
8:00
p.m. |
Keynote
Speaker: John Bachmann (Science Director, EPA OAQPS)
“The
importance of measurements of particulate carbon and organic
particle fractions for regulation and environmental assessment
on a local, regional, and global scale. Unifying PM health/NAAQS,
visibility/haze, and regional/global climate themes.” |
8:30
p.m. |
ADJOURN |
|
TUESDAY
MARCH 4, 2003 |
7:30 |
Registration Continues |
8:00
|
WELCOME
by John Ninnemann, Dean of Arts and Sciences, Fort
Lewis College |
~Questions
& Floor Discussions~ |
8:15 |
I.
What is elemental carbon and how do definitions differ for
different applications? What are the OC and EC
properties that are of importance to human health, visibility,
climate, and source attribution? To what extent can a single
analytical method or protocol meet these different needs?
TOPIC
LEADER: Robert Cary, President, Sunset Laboratory |
9:15 |
II.
What options exist for fundamental and traceable OC and
EC standards? What standards have been used in
the past? How well do these represent properties of user
communities? What other standards might be added? How can
these be created, maintained, and disseminated?
TOPIC
LEADER: Lloyd Currie, Emeritus Fellow, National
Inst. of Standards & Technology
Follow Up Presentation—"On
the Distribution of the Blank." L.A. Currie and J.M.
Conny (NIST) |
10:15 |
Brief
Break |
10:30 |
III.
How does the sample affect the measurement of different
carbon fractions? How do properties of particles
on a filter differ from those in ambient air? How do different
compounds react with heat and among themselves to create
pyrolized carbon? How do different filter loadings affect
optical measures of pyrolysis? Under what conditions might
other carbon-containing components (e.g., carbonates) be
detected as OC or EC? What additional information should
be reported with OC and EC values to evaluate the precision
and validity of an OC/EC split?
TOPIC
LEADER: Judith Chow, Desert Research Institute
Follow Up Presentation 1—"Effects
of iron oxides on the determination of organic and elemental
carbon using thermal optical techniques." Kochy
Fung, AtmAA, Calabasas, CA
Follow Up Presentation 2—
“Measurement of Carbonate Minerals in Aerosol Samples.”
Johann Engelbrecht, Desert Research Institute,
Reno, Nevada |
11:30 |
Poster Viewing Time |
Noon |
LUNCH
and Poster Viewing |
1:00
|
IV.
What are the important parameters that need to be defined
for a carbonaceous aerosol analysis and how should these
be documented for different analysis protocols?
How do temperature plateaus, analysis times, combustion
atmospheres, heating rates, and optical pyrolysis monitoring
affect the definition of carbon fractions? What differences
in analysis protocols should be reported with OC and EC
concentrations?
TOPIC
LEADER: Hélène Cachier, LSCE/CFR,
laboratoire mixte CEA-CNRS, France |
2:00 |
V.
What specific compounds are likely to evolve during different
temperature fractions of thermal evolution methods used
to analyze carbonaceous aerosols? To what extent
do similar compounds evaporate within definable temperature
groupings? How well do current temperature-defined fractions
defined useful groupings? How might temperature fractions
or the detection of thermally-evolved products be optimized
for applications such as source attribution?
TOPIC
LEADER: Joellen Lewtas, Senior Research Scientist,
US EPA/Office of Research & Dev’t/Nat’l
Exposure Research Lab
Follow
Up Presentation 1—"Organic Carbon
Concentration and Composition in Fine Particulate Matter
Collected During ARIES Study." Barbara Zielinska,
Desert Research Institute, Reno, Nevada
Follow
Up Presentation 2—"Insights from
Thermal Analysis of Individual Organic Compounds, Mixtures,
Black Carbon Surrogates, Airborne Particulate Matter and
Extracts." L. A. Gundel, Environmental
Energy Technologies Division, Lawrence Berkeley National
Lab
|
3:00 |
VI.
How does carbonaceous particle composition, shape, and size
affect optical properties in the air and when sampled on
a filter? How might optical properties of particles
in the air differ from those collected on a filter? How
might filter transmittance and reflectance change during
heating as particle morphology and composition change? Why
might optical transmission and reflectance give different
pyrolysis corrections?
TOPIC
LEADER: Kirk Fuller, Research Scientist, National
Space Science and Technology Center, Univ. of Alabama |
4:00 |
Brief Break |
4:15 |
VII.
How might current analysis methods be enhanced or combined
to obtain more information about the nature of OC, EC, and
other carbon fractions in filter samples? What
can be done with existing analysis methods and samples?
What might be provided by collocated measurements? What
hardware and software changes would permit more of the commonly
applied protocols to be applied with the same analytical
instruments?
TOPIC
LEADER: Hans Hansson, Air Pollution Laboratory,
Institute of Applied Environmental Research and Department
of Meteorology, Stockholm University, Sweden |
5:15 |
VIII.
What new and innovative sampling, analytical, and interpretive
techniques are needed to determine the properties and sources
of carbonaceous aerosol in the atmosphere? What
is the role of in situ and laboratory analysis now and in
the future? How can multiple measurements in space and time
assist in the interpretation of and validation of OC/EC
fractions? How might new technologies satisfy the needs
of multiple users? How might they better quantify OC and
EC sources for emissions reduction strategies?
TOPIC
LEADER: Hans Moosmüller, Research Professor,
Desert Research Institute
Follow Up Presentation—"Source
Apportionment Using Semi-Continuous Measurement of OC, EC,
and Other Markers of Combustion Emissions." Delbert
J. Eatough, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah |
6:15 |
Closing
and Poster Viewing |
Tuesday
Evening |
Topic
Leaders and Breakout Group Leaders meet to design Breakout
Group Interaction, Identify Specific Outcomes, Compose Questions
to be Addressed. Continue early morning Wed. if necessary. |
|
|
WEDNESDAY,
MARCH 5, 2003 |
8:30 |
KEYNOTE
— Dr. Bruce Doddridge, National Science Foundation“The
importance of OC and EC for health, climate and visibility
from the point of view of the NSF” |
8:50 |
Updates
of Current Projects (Strictly limited to five minutes each)
1. Sylvia Edgerton, Pacific Northwest National
Laboratory: "Coordination of OCEC research between
the air quality and climate science community, particularly
the possibility that exist through DOE's Atmospheric Radiation
Measurement (ARM) Program"
2. Paul Solomon, EPA: “A brief overview
of EPA/ORD ambient PM methods research program.”
3. Peter Hyde, Arizona Dept. of Environmental
Quality: "OC/EC Considerations in Phoenix and Downwind
Class I Areas"
4. Philip Hopke, Clarkson University: "Continuous
Characterization of Carbon in Fine Particulate Matter"5.
Antony Chen, DRI: "Measuring Elemental Carbon Absorption
Using a Dual Thermal Optical Reflectance/Transmittance Analyzer"
5. Antony Chen, DRI: "Measuring elemental
carbon absorption using a dual thermal optical reflectance/transmittance
analyzer."
6. Jianzhen Yu, Hong Kong University: “Charring
Minimization in Thermal Analysis of Aerosol Carbon”
& “Uncertainties in Optical Charring Correction
Schemes.”
7. William Malm, Natl Park Service/CIRA: "Implications
of using OC/EC to estimate fire and SOA contributions to
carbonaceous material"
8. Rich Scheffe, EPA: "Reconciling Carbon
Measurements Between the EPA Speciation Trends and IMPROVE
Networks."
9. John Watson: "Secondary Organic Aerosol
Research Strategy Update"
10. Joellen Lewtas/Barbara Zielinska announce
the next workshop on —“Organic Speciation”
|
10:00 |
Focus
Group Sessions (John
Watson will describe structure & selection process) |
Noon |
LUNCH |
1:30 |
Breakout
Group Reports |
2:30 |
Brainstorming
Consensus Session |
3:30 |
ADJOURN |
|
Thursday
& Friday, March 6-7, 2003 ~ (Exclusively
for preselected lead presenters, facilitators, sponsors, and
scribes to draft of the OCEC Research Strategy.) |
Return to Top of Page
|