An International Workshop
for the
Development of Research Strategies
for Sampling and Analysis of Organic and Elemental Carbon Fractions
in Atmospheric Aerosols
March 3, 4 &
5, 2003
Durango, Colorado
("OC/EC International
Workshop")
By the time it was over, 107 scientists from 18
states, and 17 countries or regions had converged on the small
mountain town of Durango in southwest Colorado to initiate development
of a research plan to guide future sampling, analysis and interlaboratory
comparisons of carbonaceous aerosols.
The workshop brought together a diverse group of chemists, physicists,
meteorologists, climatologists, graduates and post-docs from academia,
government, and industry. During the two days of intense discussions,
they shared ideas with the expressed intention of enhancing technological
and research applications in the areas of visibility, global climate
and human health. A considerable amount of information on the
workshop’s eight technical questions, prepared before the
gathering, was recorded during floor discussions and focus group
exchanges.
By most accounts, despite significant challenges, the exchange
of ideas and data represents a good start in capturing and communicating
what is not known about carbonaceous aerosols, what we need to
know, and how we can work together to tackle the challenges. Topics,
such as reconciling different methods in order to increase the
instances of comparable data across laboratories and standardization
received much attention, however the prospectus of reaching consensus
and perhaps even general agreement anytime soon seemed a long
time away
With all that was accomplished, the gathering merely
marked the beginning of a follow-up phase of drafting a research
plan that describes, in considerable detail, potential projects,
funding sources and how to improve inter-laboratory communication.
Many participants acknowledge that now a fresh opportunity exists
for more long-term comparisons of data to be conducted and having
a broader international community to work together on this.
The day after the workshop, a group of eight volunteers stayed
behind and began outlining the research plan. They listed six
themes, or topics, for further, detailed, development: Definitions;
Standardization; Thermal and Optical Filter Analysis; Organic
Speciation and Sampling; Carbon Physical Properties, and; Innovative
Instrumentation. The themes reflect key points brought out during
workshop discussion.
The plan is expected to be utilized as a reference tool for planning
research projects in the short-, mid-, and long terms. During
the next couple of months, the intention is to have a number of
participants develop and format a first draft, then circulate
it to the broader aerosol research community for further input
and development. A major guiding principle is to allow all who
wish to contribute to the plan’s content and to achieving
the challenging, yet rewarding, goal of improving research on
carbon particulates in the atmosphere. The key to this is to utilize
workshops like the OC/EC International Workshop to stimulate an
inclusive, continual collaborative communication among all those
involved in research related to atmospheric aerosols.
The goal is to finalize the plan within 12 months, in time for
the next planned workshop on Organic Speciation, set to be held
around late winter-early spring 2004.
The spirit of camaraderie and sincere dedication of the diverse
workshop participants to the subject matter and to cultivating
closer international communication is a significant sign that
the OC/EC Research Plan has a promising future.
Sincere thanks go to the National Science Foundation, the Environmental
Protection Agency’s Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards,
and National Exposure Research Lab for sponsoring the workshop
and its follow-up research plan development. Thanks also go to
the Western Regional Air Partnership for supporting ongoing activities
in the months to come.
The “OC/EC International Workshop” is second in a
series of workshops planned by a growing network of partners working
to advance research that enhances understanding of visibility,
global climate and human exposure issues. Members include EPA
Region 8, EPA Office of Research and Development, National Park
Service, Fort Lewis College, and Desert Research Institute. Many
others, too numerous to list, contribute to core organizing activities
and research plan development. You can learn who they are by merely
staying abreast of ongoing activities, or getting involved yourself.
The first workshop, Secondary Organic Aerosols Workshop, was
held Feb. 4-5, 2002 in Reno, Nevada. A Research Plan is also being
developed for that subject, a draft of which can be viewed on
the SOA Website.
Dr. John Watson, Desert Research Institute, will facilitate the
workshop, assisted by Tim Richard, MA., Fort Lewis College/Community
Services, workshop/event coordinator.
For more information about the workshop and the Research Plan
for Organic and Elemental Carbon, explore this Website, contact
Tim Richard at (970) 247-7066, John Watson (775) 674-7046, or
any of the topic leaders who led discussions.
The Office of Community Services assists area communities, state
and federal agencies, and non-profit organizations in addressing
social, economic and ecological needs. It coordinates projects
in human services, land-use planning, historic preservation, and
public policy.
The following context-setting action statements initially guided
workshop discussions:
- Revisit fundamental approaches to addressing primary and
secondary organic carbon and black/elemental carbon;
- Clarify definitions of certain terminology, such as black
carbon;
- Optimize methods for quantifying ambient concentrations of
carbonaceous aerosols;
- Emphasize climate-related issues, as well as public health
and the Regional Haze Rule;
- Develop criteria to enhance fundamental inter-laboratory communication
in the interest of creating greater uniformity in how measurements
are done.
Motivation for the workshop stems from research needs to:
- Specify thermal evolution carbon temperature fractions that
separate organic compounds into more logical groupings than
currently applied fractions;
- Review, evaluate, and compare light scattering and absorption
models;
- Evaluate methods to measure black carbon as a normalization
for primary and secondary organic carbon;
- Define and organize follow-up topical workshops on organic
aerosol issues;
- Create and disseminate calibration and performance testing
standards, and;
- Develop and apply extraction and derivatization procedures
that optimize organic aerosol recovery and quantification.
Return to the Top
|